Cyclingnews Verdict
Castelli's Alpha 150 is the warmest jacket the brand makes, but it isn't one to reach for when it's truly freezing. For long, steady rides when it's cold, it's great, with a lovely cut and good features, but the breathability is more of a curse than a blessing on many occasions.
Reasons to buy
- +
Excellently cut
- +
Internal warmer is well thought out
- +
Sleeves are a good length
- +
Very breathable, considering how warm it is
Reasons to avoid
- -
Too breathable for very cold rides
- -
High RRP for the warmth on offer
- -
Internal warmer only has a 1-way zip
You can trust Cyclingnews
Castelli’s jacket range has gone on a fair old journey in recent years. The Gabba and Perfetto have been overhauled, and everything is now PFAS-free.
The Alpha 150 is the Italian brand’s most wintery and most expensive outer layer, featuring an inbuilt fluffy body warmer to really seal you in and, I presume, seal a top spot in my guide to the best winter cycling jackets.
I’ve been testing it out throughout last winter, and through a fortuitously timed cold snap in recent weeks that has left the air thick with freezing mists and rich fog. I do like it as a jacket, but like many recent Castelli options I’ve been testing out, the suggested temperature range is perhaps a little too cold for reality. The flip side is that the breathability is excellent, so as long as you don’t stop, it’s less of an issue.
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
Design and aesthetics
Eight colours for such an expensive jacket does feel like a recipe for the unpopular ones to go on sale eventually, but they are all at least part of a pleasing spectrum.
For my part, I tested out the ‘mango mojito’ colour, which is a posh way of saying ‘yellow’. It’s the platonic ideal of yellow; primary, bright, unfussy, and I was glad of it in the gloom versus the more subdued Assos jackets I’ve also been testing alongside it.
The form is tailored but not skin-tight, with enough room to layer up a little bit underneath, at least with a thicker long-sleeve jersey and a winter base layer. You get a high, fleece-lined collar and very neat cuffs that feature a tight, stretchy synthetic cuff that surrounds the wrist, and a looser yellow main fabric over the top that I’m sure does little practically but certainly improves the aesthetics.
Open up the main double zip, either through the big, easy-to-pull-with-gloves-on toggle at the top or the normal zip tab at the bottom, and you’ll reveal a Polartec Alpha inbuilt gilet. The rear panel is free-floating, attached only at the sides and top so it articulates more easily and I assume compresses less.
The latest race content, interviews, features, reviews and expert buying guides, direct to your inbox!
The front is two simple panels with a low-cut neckline, so that you can use the main zip to cool the neck or accommodate a neck warmer, and secured by a smaller one-way zip. I could do with this also being 2-way, for reasons of pocket access, but I imagine Castelli envisioned it being used perhaps with just a deep winter base layer underneath.
The main fabric is Castelli’s exclusive ‘150g Polartec® AirCore™ electrospun air-permeable membrane’, which is alleged to be windproof while also remaining highly breathable. To this end, it is. Castelli also claims it can ‘stand up to everything except all-day driving rain’. It can’t. If it’s going to rain, wear something else; a waterproof jacket, perhaps.
It is relatively lightweight in feel. My size medium tips the scales at 324g, 70g less than an equivalent Assos jacket that I’ve been testing, but spread over your whole torso you’re not really going to notice that difference. The relative softness and flexibility of that Aircore outer fabric does make it feel lighter compared to stiffer, hardier options.
At the back, you get a reflective piping sewn under the standard three rear pockets and above a stretchy, neoprene-like waistband that is dropped far enough to cover even non-modern jerseys, though again, I suspect this is meant to just go over a base layer.
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
Performance
This is a good jacket; I do want to get that on record first. I do think the suggested temperature range is a little ambitious, however, and I don’t think you can realistically use this comfortably in anything below about 5ºC if you plan on stopping for any time at all.
The issue comes not from the added cosy insulation, but from that AirCore fabric. I had the same issues with the DoDiCi jacket, and my colleague Josh had with the previous Perfetto RoS 3; it’s just a little too breathable, so you don’t keep as much heat in as you think you will and you get a little colder than you’d like.
A few commutes around 6º, with a merino base layer and a merino long-sleeve jersey underneath, it started to feel a little on the cool side, and when things hovered around zero, I often found myself reaching for my Albion Ultralight Insulated Jacket to slip over the top as a breathability modifier.
The wind resistance was perfectly good; I never felt like the breeze was scything through the fabric even on fast descents, so I do think it’s just a function of just how breathable the outer is. If you’re doing higher-output riding in the winter, then it does make more sense, but for those longer, steadier winter miles it’s just not quite right.
That aside, when I did get the temperature right, I found it was really excellent. When you use it when it’s a little warmer - somewhere between about 7 and 12 degrees (44-54 degrees F) - on less intense rides, it keeps you just the right temperature, and the added breathability means when you get hot on climbs you don’t immediately get drenched and then freeze.
If you do get a little toasty, it’s very easy to ventilate yourself back into a comfortable range. The interior Polartec Alpha gilet thing is so breathable at the front that when you unzip the main outer zip you can feel the wind cooling you immediately.
I found a few centimetres at the top and bottom of the zip undone was often sufficient to keep me where I wanted if I was cooking a little, but on the whole this was never a jacket I ever overheated in, and I feel like I’d have to try really hard and layer very badly to get it wrong to the point where I’d become a sweaty mess at the side of the road. The most I ever really had to do was take a neck warmer off.
The cut is also excellent. The sleeves are long enough to not expose my wrists, even as a very gangly chap, and there’s enough room that I never felt constricted even with an additional jersey between my jacket and my base layer. I don’t think you’ll have a great time if you try and wear a thicker mid layer, as you can do with some of the Assos deep winter layers I’ve tested, but a thick winter jersey is totally doable.
This brings me to the pockets; the three on the actual jacket itself are great, easy to access and roomy enough to house things like a light waterproof shell or a pair of gloves with ease alongside the usual suspects.
My main annoyance comes with the fact that the internal fluffy gilet zip isn’t 2-way. I almost always wear a jersey under my winter jackets, even if it’s just a thin one. It gives me three extra pockets, as much as anything else, but with this zip arrangement, you just can’t get in easily. It’s a minor gripe, but a gripe nonetheless.
View Original
View Original
View Original
View Original
Value
At $645 or £360 it’s a very expensive jacket, significantly more than the likes of the exceptional Assos Equipe R Winter Jacket, one I would argue is superior in performance across a wider range of temperatures.
While I did (and still do) very much enjoy using it, given I found it better suited to longer, lower-intensity riding in slightly warmer conditions than advertised, for many of you I suspect you can get the same level of insulation for a lot less outlay, and while you won’t have the same breathability, this won’t necessarily be such a problem for slower cold-weather riding unless you run very hot indeed.
Verdict
Castelli’s Alpha 150 jacket may be the warmest the brand makes, but if you’re going anywhere near actual freezing conditions, then I suggest this isn’t the jacket to reach for, as it’s just too breathable to keep you at a comfortable temperature.
For longer, lower-intensity riding at high single figures, it’s dreamy, comfortable, good-looking, and well finished, but it’s a lot of money to drop on a jacket like this when cheaper options will do the same thing in many cases.
Fit |
Exactly what I'd want in a winter jacket. Close but with enough room for a choice few key layers. |
10/10 |
Protection |
It's simply not as warm as advertised, especially once you stop riding hard. |
5/10 |
Features |
The internal vest is great, and the hip valuable pocket is much better when you're all gloved up and less dextrous. |
9/10 |
Breathability |
Extremely breathable (too breathable, to be honest). No chance of getting sweaty unless you get your layers very wrong. |
10/10 |
Value |
For what it offers you can get the same warmth for a lot less outlay, and the breathability won't be too much of an issue unless you're riding hell for leather up a climb. |
6/10 |
Overall |
Row 5 - Cell 1 | 80% |
Will joined the Cyclingnews team as a reviews writer in 2022, having previously written for Cyclist, BikeRadar and Advntr. He’s tried his hand at most cycling disciplines, from the standard mix of road, gravel, and mountain bike, to the more unusual like bike polo and tracklocross. He’s made his own bike frames, covered tech news from the biggest races on the planet, and published countless premium galleries thanks to his excellent photographic eye. Also, given he doesn’t ever ride indoors he’s become a real expert on foul-weather riding gear. His collection of bikes is a real smorgasbord, with everything from vintage-style steel tourers through to superlight flat bar hill climb machines.
You must confirm your public display name before commenting
Please logout and then login again, you will then be prompted to enter your display name.