Skip to main content

Philippa York analysis: Yates and Carapaz on top before Giro's first mountain test

Giro d'Italia 2022 Philippa York analysis first rest day, Carapaz and Yates GC battle
GC contender Richard Carapaz and Simon Yates have made a mark during the first three stages in Hungary (Image credit: Getty Images/composite)

The opening stages of the Giro d'Italia in Hungary are done and dusted and there are promising signs of a fascinating battle developing between the two main favourites.

The first strike went to Richard Carapaz who was on the right side of the four-second split at the opening day uphill finish in Visegrád. Okay, it was mainly caused the Caleb Ewan crash in the sprint, but nevertheless, the Ineos Grenadiers leader was well placed for the majority of the 5.5km climb to the line.

Strangely, there was no sign of Simon Yates near the front at any time on the climb when he ought to have been paying close attention to his main rival. However, the next day he produced a convincing time trial in Budapest that gave him a 24-second advantage as the race heads to Sicily.

Tuesday's 22.8km summit finish at Mount Etna will be an indication of how everyone is climbing – even though it's fairly regular in gradient. It is long enough to sort out those who were maybe planning to come good in the final week from those who are in top form already.

It's first strike to Simon Yates in the psychological battle though. The buffer he has over the other GC contenders (such as 18 seconds to João Almeida and 24 to Carapaz) may be small, but it all matters as it clearly shows the form he's in.

The wonder now is whether Tom Dumoulin, who lies just five seconds behind Yates, is or isn't going to challenge for the maglia rosa. The route chosen up the side of Etna doesn't contain the steep changeable ramps that might have seen him struggle, so there's the chance that Ineos and BikeExchange-Jayco let someone else take responsibility for the race lead for a while.

Looking at it objectively, Jumbo-Visma are the perfect squad for that as they haven't come with a sprinter and all their resources are geared towards stage and overall results.

Like Almeida and Carapaz, most of the more climbing-orientated GC riders are already huddled in a group roughly 20 seconds or so behind Yates and with the stage 4 finish likely to come down to a small group sprint, guys like Bilbao, Almeida and Mollema will be watching each other quite closely. 

Something to note is that the wind is quite often a factor on the upper slopes of Etna, so it's quite difficult for the purer climbers like Bardet or Landa to carve out a major difference.

So, then, there's definitely a scenario where the big teams allow someone like Wilco Kelderman to sneak away. Or even Richie Porte and why not a final fling from Vincenzo Nibali on his home turf, though it's more likely we'll see Miguel Angel López to the fore for Astana.

Beyond the maglia rosa – the sprinters

BALATONFURED HUNGARY MAY 08 Mark Cavendish of United Kingdom and Team QuickStep Alpha Vinyl celebrates winning the stage on the podium ceremony after the 105th Giro dItalia 2022 Stage 3 a 201km stage from Kaposvr to Balatonfred Giro WorldTour on May 08 2022 in Balatonfured Hungary Photo by Tim de WaeleGetty Images

Mark Cavendish celebrated his 16th career Giro stage victory on Sunday (Image credit: Tim de Waele/Getty Images)

For the coming week the big question outside of the maglia rosa fight could well be: Is Mark Cavendish going to treat us to a rerun of last year's Tour de France?

It's quite remarkable that, given the right guys working for him, he can still outsprint the likes of Ewan, Fernando Gaviria, Arnaud Démare et al, and there are another two chances in the opening week that ought to be a mass sprint.

How the other teams go about stopping the QuickStep lead-out train operating will be key to what happens, but you get the feeling that Caleb Ewan will eventually escape the bad luck that's attached itself to him.

Then there's Intermarché-Wanty Gobert leader Binian Girmay who will definitely win a stage, though he might have to wait until next weekend when the terrain will have sapped some of the pure speed from everyone's legs. However, he'll then be up against Mathieu van der Poel again who has a habit of doing the unexpected just when you thought his involvement was slightly less prominent, as was the case in Visegrád.

If there wasn't Mount Etna to climb, then van der Poel would possibly have stayed in the race lead until next Sunday. But then you look at the profile of Friday's stage 7 to Potenza that has the potential to turn the race on its head and that's a very Mathieu van der Poel thing to do.

The conclusion from Hungary's contribution to the 105th Giro d'Italia is that the pre-race favourites for GC are certainly present and waiting to strike, though nobody is lost yet – even from those considered outsiders.

Then there's the sprinters, who all have to contend with the fact that Mark Cavendish might say he's not the fastest or the strongest, but can still beat them when you need to be fast and strong.