Skip to main content

2012 Scott Spark range - First ride review

Image 1 of 53

Scott's new Spark sports better suspension, more progressive geometry, and improved aesthetics across the board.

Scott's new Spark sports better suspension, more progressive geometry, and improved aesthetics across the board. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 2 of 53

The Scott Spark's Schwalbe Rocket Ron tires are very fast rolling for a full-knob tire but sketchy on loose terrain.

The Scott Spark's Schwalbe Rocket Ron tires are very fast rolling for a full-knob tire but sketchy on loose terrain. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 3 of 53

Front derailleurs are mounted directly to the swingarm on new Sparks for more consistent shifting throughout the travel range. The compact mounting tabs also allow more freedom in seat tube shaping.

Front derailleurs are mounted directly to the swingarm on new Sparks for more consistent shifting throughout the travel range. The compact mounting tabs also allow more freedom in seat tube shaping. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 4 of 53

Though billed as a lightweight race or trail bike, Scott still specs a more versatile 180mm front rotor.

Though billed as a lightweight race or trail bike, Scott still specs a more versatile 180mm front rotor. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 5 of 53

Sag gradients on the RockShox SID fork ease initial setup.

Sag gradients on the RockShox SID fork ease initial setup. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 6 of 53

RockShox crafted a custom DNA3 damper exclusively for Scott with three settings: full-open, a shorter and firmer traction mode, and full lockout.

RockShox crafted a custom DNA3 damper exclusively for Scott with three settings: full-open, a shorter and firmer traction mode, and full lockout. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 7 of 53

5 is the new 4 - Scott's new Spark platform features five inches of travel front and rear. 29" bikes get four inches at both ends.

5 is the new 4 - Scott's new Spark platform features five inches of travel front and rear. 29" bikes get four inches at both ends. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 8 of 53

The very lightweight chassis on the carbon fiber Scott Spark frames are perfect for 2x10 drivetrains - 29er riders might have a tough time with the 26x36T low gear on very long climbs, though.

The very lightweight chassis on the carbon fiber Scott Spark frames are perfect for 2x10 drivetrains - 29er riders might have a tough time with the 26x36T low gear on very long climbs, though. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 9 of 53

The tidy TwinLoc remote doesn't take up much room on the bar.

The tidy TwinLoc remote doesn't take up much room on the bar. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 10 of 53

SRAM XX controls on the top-end RC-level Sparks are lightweight and shift smoothly. Brake feel was disappointingly variable on our early test bikes, though, despite Avid's redesigned internal architecture.

SRAM XX controls on the top-end RC-level Sparks are lightweight and shift smoothly. Brake feel was disappointingly variable on our early test bikes, though, despite Avid's redesigned internal architecture. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 11 of 53

Scott has wisely elected to spec wider bars than on most companies' cross-country race bikes.

Scott has wisely elected to spec wider bars than on most companies' cross-country race bikes. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 12 of 53

The internally routed derailleur cables on carbon Scott Spark frames reemerge down at the bottom bracket shell. They don't actually hang as far below the bottom bracket as one might think and the system is fairly easy to run, too.

The internally routed derailleur cables on carbon Scott Spark frames reemerge down at the bottom bracket shell. They don't actually hang as far below the bottom bracket as one might think and the system is fairly easy to run, too. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 13 of 53

Scott's TwinLoc remote works as advertised but it also produces a cluttered mass of cables up front.

Scott's TwinLoc remote works as advertised but it also produces a cluttered mass of cables up front. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 14 of 53

All 2012 Scott Sparks unfortunately stick with quick-release fork tips instead of the increasingly popular - and notably stiffer - thru-axle setups.

All 2012 Scott Sparks unfortunately stick with quick-release fork tips instead of the increasingly popular - and notably stiffer - thru-axle setups. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 15 of 53

The new DT Swiss Nude 2 shock is a big improvement over the first-generation's original Nude. Small-bump sensitivity is much better, the stroke is more smoothly progressive with less of a saddle in the middle, and the tidier inline twin air chamber design leaves more room in the main triangle for bottles.

The new DT Swiss Nude 2 shock is a big improvement over the first-generation's original Nude. Small-bump sensitivity is much better, the stroke is more smoothly progressive with less of a saddle in the middle, and the tidier inline twin air chamber design leaves more room in the main triangle for bottles. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 16 of 53

New carbon Scott Sparks get a newly kinked seat tube for 2012.

New carbon Scott Sparks get a newly kinked seat tube for 2012. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 17 of 53

2012 Scott Sparks get a new bridge tying the seat stays together.

2012 Scott Sparks get a new bridge tying the seat stays together. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 18 of 53

2012 Scott Spark buyers will no longer have to struggle to find aftermarket seatposts as the company has moved away from the old 34.9mm diameter to a more standard 31.6mm size.

2012 Scott Spark buyers will no longer have to struggle to find aftermarket seatposts as the company has moved away from the old 34.9mm diameter to a more standard 31.6mm size. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 19 of 53

Scott has moved back to symmetrical chain stays on the 2012 Spark.

Scott has moved back to symmetrical chain stays on the 2012 Spark. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 20 of 53

A stock rear thru-axle secures the rear end more stoutly than quick-release ones. Interchangeable chips allow users to switch to 135mm quick-release or thru-axle standards if desired, too.

A stock rear thru-axle secures the rear end more stoutly than quick-release ones. Interchangeable chips allow users to switch to 135mm quick-release or thru-axle standards if desired, too. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 21 of 53

Scott has switched to post mount tabs and tucked the rear brake caliper inside the rear triangle on new carbon fiber Sparks for better protection from impact and lighter weight, not to mention a stouter foundation for squeal-free braking.

Scott has switched to post mount tabs and tucked the rear brake caliper inside the rear triangle on new carbon fiber Sparks for better protection from impact and lighter weight, not to mention a stouter foundation for squeal-free braking. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 22 of 53

The simple black-and-white paintjob accentuates the newly sweeping lines of the 2012 carbon fiber Scott Spark.

The simple black-and-white paintjob accentuates the newly sweeping lines of the 2012 carbon fiber Scott Spark. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 23 of 53

The main pivot has dropped about 10mm relative to earlier Sparks for more neutral pedaling performance in the inner ring on modern 2x10 drivetrains.

The main pivot has dropped about 10mm relative to earlier Sparks for more neutral pedaling performance in the inner ring on modern 2x10 drivetrains. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 24 of 53

New for 2012 Sparks is user-convertible geometry on all Spark frames. Even in the high/steep setting, the head tube is slacker than what was previously considered standard for short-travel cross-country bikes for more stable and predictable handling at speed.

New for 2012 Sparks is user-convertible geometry on all Spark frames. Even in the high/steep setting, the head tube is slacker than what was previously considered standard for short-travel cross-country bikes for more stable and predictable handling at speed. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 25 of 53

Scott has added tapered head tubes to all 2012 Spark frames.

Scott has added tapered head tubes to all 2012 Spark frames. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 26 of 53

Press-fit bottom bracket cups on the new carbon fiber Scott Spark frame allow for a very wide down tube and less weight as there are no longer any aluminum inserts required for threaded cups.

Press-fit bottom bracket cups on the new carbon fiber Scott Spark frame allow for a very wide down tube and less weight as there are no longer any aluminum inserts required for threaded cups. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 27 of 53

Scott again uses carbon fiber dropouts on the top-end Sparks but newly interchangeable bolt-in aluminum inserts allow for multiple quick-release and thru-axle rear hub standards.

Scott again uses carbon fiber dropouts on the top-end Sparks but newly interchangeable bolt-in aluminum inserts allow for multiple quick-release and thru-axle rear hub standards. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 28 of 53

All in all, the new DT Swiss Nude 2 rear shock and forged one-piece aluminum link yields a much cleaner look than in years past.

All in all, the new DT Swiss Nude 2 rear shock and forged one-piece aluminum link yields a much cleaner look than in years past. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 29 of 53

Dropouts on the alloy Spark frame are heavily relieved to shave weight but still maintain good stiffness.

Dropouts on the alloy Spark frame are heavily relieved to shave weight but still maintain good stiffness. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 30 of 53

Though obviously heavier than the top-end Truvativ XX model, the hollow-forged aluminum X9 crankset offered up excellent shift performance during our brief test period.

Though obviously heavier than the top-end Truvativ XX model, the hollow-forged aluminum X9 crankset offered up excellent shift performance during our brief test period. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 31 of 53

The TwinLoc levers integrate nicely with SRAM's latest clamp designs.

The TwinLoc levers integrate nicely with SRAM's latest clamp designs. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 32 of 53

Our alloy Sparks came with nicer components than will stock bikes but even so, refreshingly wide bars will be a common theme.

Our alloy Sparks came with nicer components than will stock bikes but even so, refreshingly wide bars will be a common theme. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 33 of 53

The alloy TwinLoc lever is nicely made with a positive feel and good ergonomics. Dual barrel adjusters allow for easy fine-tuning for the shock and fork, too.

The alloy TwinLoc lever is nicely made with a positive feel and good ergonomics. Dual barrel adjusters allow for easy fine-tuning for the shock and fork, too. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 34 of 53

Kinked and asymmetrical seat tubes are a common feature with all of the new Sparks.

Kinked and asymmetrical seat tubes are a common feature with all of the new Sparks. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 35 of 53

Scott uses slightly wider rims on the 29" Sparks than on the 26" ones, saying that the bigger tires are better matched to rims that provide extra casing support.

Scott uses slightly wider rims on the 29" Sparks than on the 26" ones, saying that the bigger tires are better matched to rims that provide extra casing support. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 36 of 53

In addition to greater claimed stiffness, the new shock link also boasts a much slimmer and more knee-friendly profile.

In addition to greater claimed stiffness, the new shock link also boasts a much slimmer and more knee-friendly profile. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 37 of 53

Scott has switched from the multi-piece link on the old Spark to a tidier-looking one-piece forged aluminum bit.

Scott has switched from the multi-piece link on the old Spark to a tidier-looking one-piece forged aluminum bit. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 38 of 53

The internally routed cables are fed into the frame just behind the newly tapered head tube. Though none of the lines are fully routed inside the tubes, feeding them through is rather straightforward.

The internally routed cables are fed into the frame just behind the newly tapered head tube. Though none of the lines are fully routed inside the tubes, feeding them through is rather straightforward. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 39 of 53

New to the 2012 Scott Spark range is a highly anticipated range of 29ers, including the top-end Spark 29 RC that features an ultralight carbon frame and an enviable mix of componentry.

New to the 2012 Scott Spark range is a highly anticipated range of 29ers, including the top-end Spark 29 RC that features an ultralight carbon frame and an enviable mix of componentry. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 40 of 53

The RockShox Reba fork on our alloy Spark testers provided excellent bump control on a wide range of terrain. We only wish they were equipped with thru-axle dropouts, too.

The RockShox Reba fork on our alloy Spark testers provided excellent bump control on a wide range of terrain. We only wish they were equipped with thru-axle dropouts, too. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 41 of 53

While Scott goes to great lengths to shave weight off of its frames, the company is still admirably progressive in including slighter larger front brake rotors.

While Scott goes to great lengths to shave weight off of its frames, the company is still admirably progressive in including slighter larger front brake rotors. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 42 of 53

The new DT Swiss Nude 2 cable spool is much easier to set up than before. That being said, it'd still be nice to have some sort of markings to help properly set up the cable tension.

The new DT Swiss Nude 2 cable spool is much easier to set up than before. That being said, it'd still be nice to have some sort of markings to help properly set up the cable tension. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 43 of 53

The hydroformed alloy Scott Spark seat tube sports a pronounced kink as well as a highly asymmetrical shape for 2012.

The hydroformed alloy Scott Spark seat tube sports a pronounced kink as well as a highly asymmetrical shape for 2012. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 44 of 53

The all-alloy rear triangles on aluminum Scott Sparks get a new seat stay bridge for 2012.

The all-alloy rear triangles on aluminum Scott Sparks get a new seat stay bridge for 2012. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 45 of 53

The full-length derailleur housings and rear brake line are all run on the underside of the down tube on the 2012 alloy Scott Spark.

The full-length derailleur housings and rear brake line are all run on the underside of the down tube on the 2012 alloy Scott Spark. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 46 of 53

Scott has moved away from asymmetrical chain stays on the alloy and carbon Spark frames for 2012.

Scott has moved away from asymmetrical chain stays on the alloy and carbon Spark frames for 2012. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 47 of 53

Alloy Sparks get the same convertible rear dropout system as on the carbon models. 142x12mm fitment is stock on complete bikes but they can easily be switched to 135mm quick-release and thru-axle standards, too.

Alloy Sparks get the same convertible rear dropout system as on the carbon models. 142x12mm fitment is stock on complete bikes but they can easily be switched to 135mm quick-release and thru-axle standards, too. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 48 of 53

The 2012 alloy Scott Spark frame switches to post mount rear brake tabs that are tucked safely inside the rear triangle.

The 2012 alloy Scott Spark frame switches to post mount rear brake tabs that are tucked safely inside the rear triangle. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 49 of 53

The main pivot housing and bottom bracket shell are formed as a single piece on the new alloy Sparks.

The main pivot housing and bottom bracket shell are formed as a single piece on the new alloy Sparks. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 50 of 53

Alloy Scott Sparks get similarly tapered and oversized head tubes as the carbon models for 2012.

Alloy Scott Sparks get similarly tapered and oversized head tubes as the carbon models for 2012. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 51 of 53

Alloy Scott Sparks are better than ever with much improved suspension, very progressive geometry, and a more refined look than previous Sparks.

Alloy Scott Sparks are better than ever with much improved suspension, very progressive geometry, and a more refined look than previous Sparks. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 52 of 53

Scott says it went with quick-release hubs with the idea that many racers will already have a quiver of wheels at their disposal. We see it as a lost opportunity for greater handling precision.

Scott says it went with quick-release hubs with the idea that many racers will already have a quiver of wheels at their disposal. We see it as a lost opportunity for greater handling precision. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)
Image 53 of 53

Just as with the 26" Sparks, the Scott Spark 29 RC features a RockShox fork but again, with quick-release dropouts instead of stouter thru-axle ones.

Just as with the 26" Sparks, the Scott Spark 29 RC features a RockShox fork but again, with quick-release dropouts instead of stouter thru-axle ones. (Image credit: Jonny Irick)

Scott's new 2012 range of Spark full-suspension bikes is no longer aimed solely at cross country racers. While the later first-gen models eventually sprouted longer forks and more trail-friendly componentry, this second-generation Spark is a wholly more proactively progressive machine straight from the get-go in terms of travel, geometry, and versatility. The family has grown, too, to 11 26" models (seven carbon, four aluminum) ranging from US$1,500-10,000 and six all-new 29" models (three carbon, three aluminum) from US$1,650-6,500.

We spent four days riding the new bikes around Scott's Sun Valley, Idaho US headquarters (plus an extra few weeks beforehand on a preproduction carbon 26" model on local trails) and walked away with a good impression of what consumers will see later this year: much improved suspension performance, surprisingly speed-friendly handling, and even a cleaner, more modern aesthetic.

Trick TwinLoc feature across the board but your thumbs will be very busy

The personality of every 2012 Spark is overwhelmingly defined by the TwinLoc user-selectable suspension settings, operated by a trick bar-mounted lever that simultaneously controls the rear shock and front fork. Upper-end models like the ones we rode can be switched on-the-fly between 120, 85, and 0mm of travel on 26" bikes and 100, 70, and 0mm of movement on 29" versions – both using a new DT Swiss Nude 2 rear shock built just for Scott (lower-end bikes get a two-mode open/lockout switch instead).

The new DT Swiss Nude 2 shock is a big improvement over the original Nude

Suspension performance in full-travel mode is significantly improved with lower breakaway thresholds as compared to the original DT Swiss Nude shock and a more smoothly progressive spring rate afterward. As a result, the new Spark is better at flattening out high-frequency trail chatter, the rear end no longer wallows in the mid-stroke as the old machine was occasionally prone to do, and in general it's easier to use the suspension to gain speed out of corners than before.

Flipping the TwinLoc switch into traction mode yields a more dramatic change than in years past. DT Swiss has managed to tuck the original Nude shock's external secondary air chamber into the main body of the Nude 2 for a more compact form factor and better bottle clearance but the end result is the same. Traction mode seals off the smaller chamber and produces a firmer and much more sharply progressive spring rate that effectively shortens the travel and also raises the sag point – something we very much appreciated during the countless long uphill grinds of Sun Valley's surrounding terrain.

Higher-end Sparks also get a new semi-analogous system on the matching RockShox fork with full open, platform, and lockout modes on the custom DNA3 compression damper. Just as with the rear end, traction mode restricts oil flow to stiffen things up and while there's no change to the air spring in this case, the end result is the same – a much firmer platform with decreased travel that's very resistant to movement for a more efficient feel.

Scott's TwinLoc remote works as advertised but it also produces a cluttered mass of cables up front

Ironically, though, both ends firm up so much that they decrease traction, in particular on technical climbs. This middle setting now seals off the bypass port in the Nude 2's compression piston, forcing all the oil to move through the shim stack and making the rear suspension much firmer in this middle setting than any old Spark ever was. Likewise, traction mode restricts oil flow in the custom RockShox DNA3 damper, too (the air chamber isn't affected up front but shunting the oil flow still yields similar reductions in effective travel), whereas the old Spark left the fork free to move.

As a result, traction mode doesn't leave much movement for smaller trail obstacles that can disrupt your rhythm or bump you off line. Thankfully, users can simply dial back the FloodGate adjuster to soften things back up but they'll also have to keep in mind that it'll soften things up in full lockout mode, too. We'd rather Scott kept the old traction mode settings that cut down on rear travel but otherwise left both dampers free to operate as needed (or at least something that doesn't restrict the oil flow quite as much as it does).

Just as you'd expect, the lockout position does just that with a rock-solid feel out back – great for long, smooth climbs or road sections on the way to the trailhead. The RockShox fork adds the familiar FloodGate blowoff threshold adjuster to help fine-tune the ride but there's nothing similar out back. The Nude2 shock will move when locked out if you hit something hard enough but it's a somewhat harsh event that finishes with a clunk at top-out.

The new DT Swiss Nude 2 rear shock and forged one-piece aluminum link yield a much cleaner look than in years past

Overall, Scott's TracLoc system is admirable in its ambition: like a car with a manual transmission, it doesn't try to do any of the thinking for you and instead provides riders with full control over how the back end behaves. Each mode works as intended for the most part but to expand on the automobile analogy, it's a little like driving an compact car with a small-displacement motor – you have to row the gearbox a lot to extract the most performance and you'll definitely pay a performance price if you're not in the right gear.

Moreover, the advent of two-ring drivetrains has prompted Scott to lower the main pivot by approximately 10mm – roughly inline with the inner chainring – for better pedaling efficiency on steeper climbs. Seated climbing in the inner ring with the rear shock fully open yields good (but not great) pedaling response but when hammering in the big ring, the new Spark answers with pronounced rear-end squat and lots of monkey motion, especially on short power climbs that require ten or twenty strong strokes to crest a rise.

So yes, TwinLoc works as advertised but new Spark riders will likely find themselves using it a lot – maybe even more than they would like.

Interestingly, the Nude2 shock that lies at the heart of the new Spark's revamped suspension system is also its biggest handicap. There's no platform-type valving whatsoever, no complex damping circuits to handle more complicated trail situations, and while small bump sensitivity is worlds better than the old Nude, it still feels well behind the latest technology from Fox Racing Shox or RockShox. The three modes are nice and all but ultimately, we were hoping for a little more up-to-date technology in each setting. As it is, the Nude 2 still feels a little old school in execution.

Scott's collaboration with DT Swiss goes back a long way and though that relationship may still be cozy, we can't help but feel it's time to cut the cord and move on to someone with more to offer.

Frame: stiffer carbon models, impressively advanced alloy ones

The unfortunate thing is that Nude2 shock's underwhelming performance mars what is otherwise an eager and high-performing chassis – at least in promise, that is (more on that in a bit).

Frame geometry is remarkably progressive for what is supposed to be Scott's flagship cross-country racer. All models feature a two-position linkage mount for adjustable geometry and in either case, it's notably slacker than what is currently considered standard: 68-68.7° for the 26" Spark and roughly a degree steeper for 29ers. Bottom brackets are quite low, too.

Fans of point-and-shoot riding styles will have to adjust their reflexes a touch in twisty sections of trail but the upside is outstanding stability at very high speed.

Suspension pivot points have been beefed up across the board with bigger shaft diameters and newly outboard bearings. Shock linkage width has decreased for much improved knee clearance but it's now a one-piece forged aluminum bit instead of the old bolt-together unit that's far cleaner and sleeker looking.

There's also a newly tapered head tube, better top tube clearance across the board, direct-mount front derailleurs that attach to the swingarm yoke, and – finally – a more standard 31.6mm seatpost diameter instead of proprietary 34.9mm one. Carbon frames also get a wider all-carbon bottom bracket with press-fit cups and a true one-piece molded front triangle instead of the molded-plus-tube-to-tube construction of Spark v1.0.

Press-fit bottom bracket cups on the new carbon fiber Scott Spark frame allow for a very wide down tube and less weight as there are no longer any aluminum inserts required for threaded cups

All complete Sparks get increasingly popular 142x12mm thru-axle rear ends for stiffness but they can also be converted to standard 135mm quick-release or 135x12mm thru-axle standards.

In total, Scott is claiming a fantastic 60 percent boost in frame stiffness over the old Spark for carbon models, all at the same 1,790g weight for a medium frame and shock.

Emphasis is on "claim" here, though, as our pre-production carbon samples didn’t quite back up those numbers. In fact, the 26" one felt strangely soft and the 29" one – while very good – wasn't the big improvement over the current Spark that we were expecting. Our pre-production medium 26" carbon tester was also a touch overweight at 1,990g though that figure also included the bulky quick-release seatpost collar, rear derailleur hanger, front derailleur mounting stub, and water bottle bolts.

Scott US marketing and PR director Adrian Montgomery confirmed our calibrated rear ends, saying these early test samples unfortunately weren't built with final lay-up schedules and were much softer than they should be. We've been promised a production bike in August so we're still holding hope that the claimed numbers hold true, particularly since if they're correct, the new carbon Spark frame should be utterly fantastic in terms of structure given the laundry list of features and Scott's proven track record with composite structures.

On a positive note, the alloy versions we tried were very impressive. We don't have actual frame weights to report but stiffness actually felt better than our out-of-spec carbon samples and roughly on par with current carbon Sparks. Aside from the extra frame weight, the alloy version will undoubtedly be the better values.

Build kit: Scott takes a confusing stance on thru-axles

Our test bikes were equipped with non-standard build kits so we won't dwell much on the performance of those components. Regardless, a few trends are worth discussing.

First off, all of the Sparks are impressively light. The top-end 26"-wheeled Spark RC is just 9.84kg (21.69lb) with DT Swiss Tricon 1450 wheels, SRAM XX and a RockShox SID RLT3 (medium frame, without pedals); the Spark 29 RC is an excellent 11.04kg (24.34lb) with wider trail-friendly DT Swiss wheels, SRAM XX and a RockShox SID 29 RLT3; an alloy 26" Spark is 11.52kg (25.40lb) with SRAM X9, DT Swiss XM 1550 Tricon wheels and a RockShox Reba; and a similarly equipped alloy 29" Spark is 12.05kg (26.57lb).

Scott has openly championed thru-axles out back but strangely enough, all Sparks will use quick-release dropouts up front. According to Montgomery, Scott's European bigwigs ultimately decided that the Spark's expected competition-oriented audience would already have a fleet of race wheels at their disposal that they wouldn't be too keen to retire. They apparently also made the argument that quick-release wheels are faster to change.

All 2012 Scott Sparks stick with quick-release fork tips instead of the increasingly popular – and notably stiffer – through-axle setups

The spare wheel argument admittedly holds some merit but that being said, Scott contradicts itself by going with a thru-axle out back – and one that's frustrating slow to change at that. Sure, the rear dropouts can be converted but those bits aren't included with complete bikes and then at that point, you end up with an essentially useless stock rear wheel.

More importantly, the open-dropout forks are noticeably flexier than their thru-axle counterparts so Scott is making a significant performance compromise in trade for a questionable increase in clearance. Strangely enough, the Scale 29 RC carbon hardtail we tested a few months ago does have a thru-axle fork – and the steering was utterly fantastic partially as a result of that.

Speaking of 29ers, Sun Valley's abundance of long, grinding climbs also highlighted another issue: the standard 2x10 gearing. The 26x36-tooth bailout works just fine for most folks with 26" wheels but there's no ratio adjustment for the 29er version's greater rollout. This is perhaps more a SRAM issue than a Scott one, though, as the top-end XX crank isn't currently offered with the more 29"-specific ratios of the second-tier X0.

Overall: promise – but not quite the delivery yet – of a brand-new day

Our early assessment of Scott's new Spark platform is clearly a little mixed. All signs point to big improvements over the predecessor and in many cases that's true: the geometry is fantastic, the frame includes all the latest bells and whistles, it's still crazy-light, and while this is purely subjective, the new look is a huge step in the right direction.

Ultimately our frustrations come from the fact that there's so much potential here that we feel is disappointingly held back by a stubborn allegiance to a shock that's rife with bells and whistles but just doesn't feel as good as its more advanced competitors.

We've still got our fingers crossed for the proper full-production tester coming in a few weeks and we'll see if our opinions change on more familiar home soil with location-specific rubber. Either way, rest assured we'll also be swapping out the Nude 2 at some point for something we feel is more appropriate for what the frame potentially has to offer.

There's greatness hidden in here – we can almost taste it.

New to the 2012 Scott Spark range is a highly anticipated range of 29ers, including the top-end Spark 29 RC that features an ultralight carbon frame and an enviable mix of componentry

This article first appeared on BikeRadar