The Alpecin-Fenix leader was clearly the strongest in the race along with Alaphilippe, jumping away from the peloton multiple times on the hills that define the race.
They were away again in the final, along with Benoît Cosnefroy, the AG2R La Mondiale rider riding a rich vein of form after the Tour de France.
In the end, Van der Poel lost out by less than half a wheel length as Alaphilippe almost repeated his Liège-Bastogne-Liège blunder by celebrating before he crossed the finish line. After the race, Van der Poel admitted his own mistakes in the sprint finish.
He went to the front of the lead trio with 700 metres to go on the final hill of Schavei but let Cosnefroy jump first 200 metres out as the Frenchman took the inside line of the final turn. Van der Poel was then boxed in the final 100 metres as Alaphilippe came around to edge to the win.
"I made a mistake I normally never make," Van der Poel told Het Nieuwsblad after the finish. "I knew the finish from last year, so I knew what I had to do. When Alaphilippe went past I knew I had waited too long.
"I was half-wheeling between him and Cosnefroy. I just waited far too long to go. I can hit myself on the head.
"I was going to do what Cosnefroy did – sprint against the fence because the others would have to come through the wind."
Van der Poel, who extended his team's Europe Tour lead over Arkéa-Samsic by a further 65 points as Warren Barguil took fifth, acknowledged that more opportunities to win will come before the season's end, but said that he would lose sleep over this result.
"I can't forgive myself for messing this up. The next race is coming soon but I can't think about that right now. I was keen to win here. This is going to make me sleep very badly."
Van der Poel's next race will be Gent-Wevelgem on Sunday, with a return to the Tour of Flanders coming a week later and then a debut at Paris-Roubaix. He'll be a prime favourite for those cobbled Classics, with any top result looking set to secure him and his team a ticket to any WorldTour race – including the Tour de France – next season.
Enjoy your first month for just £1 / $1 / €1
*Read 5 free articles per month without a subscription
Try your first month for just £1 / $1 / €1
Daniel Ostanek has been a staff writer at Cyclingnews since August 2019, having joined in 2017 as a freelance contributor and later part-time production editor. Before Cyclingnews, he was published in numerous publications around the cycling world, including Procycling, CyclingWeekly, CyclingTips, Cyclist, and Rouleur, among others. As well as reporting and writing news, Daniel runs the 'How to watch' content on Cyclingnews and takes on live race text coverage throughout the season.
Daniel has reported from the world's top races, including the Tour de France, and has interviewed a number of the sport's biggest stars, including Egan Bernal, Wout van Aert, Remco Evenepoel, Mark Cavendish, and Anna van der Breggen. Daniel rides a 2002 Landbouwkrediet Colnago C40 and his favourite races are Tro-Bro Léon, Strade Bianche, and the Vuelta a España.
Thank you for signing up to Cycling News. You will receive a verification email shortly.
There was a problem. Please refresh the page and try again.