Skip to main content

Stetina disturbed by Giro d'Italia descending competition

Image 1 of 5

Peter Stetina (Trek-Segafredo)

Peter Stetina (Trek-Segafredo) (Image credit: Courtesy of Polartec-Kometa)
Image 2 of 5

Taylor Phinney (BMC) and teammate Peter Stetina show off recovering legs at todays stage start

Taylor Phinney (BMC) and teammate Peter Stetina show off recovering legs at todays stage start (Image credit: Jonathan Devich/
Image 3 of 5

Peter Stetina signed a new contract with Trek Segafredo after impressing in 2016

Peter Stetina signed a new contract with Trek Segafredo after impressing in 2016 (Image credit: Cyclingnews)
Image 4 of 5

The Chicken Man cheers on Peter Stetina (Trek-Segafredo)

The Chicken Man cheers on Peter Stetina (Trek-Segafredo) (Image credit: Jonathan Devich/
Image 5 of 5

Peter Stetina (Trek-Segafredo)

Peter Stetina (Trek-Segafredo)

American Peter Stetina has added his weight to objections against to the Giro d'Italia's new "Premio Miglior Discesista" classification for best descender. The Trek-Segafredo rider suffered a nearly career-ending crash in the 2015 Vuelta al Pais Vasco two years ago, and knows first hand what it's like to become 'collateral damage' in a fight that he never entered into.

The stage included the descent of the Alto del Vivero, a category 2 climb, and a sprint in Bilbao. Stetina's group was hurtling toward the finish when, with 500m to go, they came upon a series of waist-high posts invisible to the approaching bunch. Stetina ran right into it, shattering his kneecap and tibia and severing his patellar tendon.

One can understand why Stetina might be outraged about a competition that could increase the level of danger in the Giro d'Italia.

"This news really disturbs me," Stetina wrote to the North American riders union (ANAPRC) executive director Michael Carcaise, adding that he hoped the CPA riders organisation would pressure RCS Sport to remove it.

Stetina called the competition a "short sighted move from someone who doesn't understand racing".

"Have they considered that myself or my colleagues could become collateral of an idiot racer's bad choices in chasing this prize?"

Stetina used the example of the 2015 Tour de France, where, on stage 16, Warren Barguil attempted a risky inside pass on Geraint Thomas during a descent, but was unable to hold his line. The Frenchman ran into Thomas, forcing him off the road where he crashed into a utility pole. Luckily he was able to continue the race, but Stetina fears that similar risky moves could cause massive crashes for riders behind who haven't chosen to race for the prize.

"There are many more variables besides one guy descending a mountain at his limit. A rider will have to pull dangerous manoeuvres around others, in the name of seconds, putting both at peril," Stetina said. "So now I am entered in this competition without a choice!

"Professional athletes are entertainers, and fans love to witness their seemingly superhuman capabilities. But they are human. They are husbands, sons, fathers, brothers, and friends. They are capable of making mistakes. Let's not set up competitions where those mistakes can have fatal consequences. We witnessed this in 2011 (Wouter Weylandt) at this very race and the organizers should have the decency to honour his memory with safer protocol, not by glorifying dangerous risk taking," Stetina concluded.

To subscribe to the Cyclingnews Podcast, click here.

Laura Weislo has been with Cyclingnews since 2006 after making a switch from a career in science. As Deputy Editor, she coordinates coverage for North American events and global news. A swimmer in her younger days, Laura made the change to cycling later in life, but was immediately swept up by a huge passion for the sport. Riding for fitness quickly gave way to the competitive urge, and a decade of racing later she can look back on a number of high profile races and say with confidence, "I started". While her racing days are over for the most part, she continues to dabble in cyclo-cross and competing against fellow pathletes on the greenways of Raleigh, North Carolina.